HomeSymptomGuideProfileJournalSymptom LibraryCommunitySupportAccount Login

Symptom Library
DescriptionStageWhat's Happening in the BrainManagement StrategiesDoctor's Diary
Repetitive Questions/ Stories | Doctor's Diary

Many families describe repetitive questioning as one of the most distressing aspects of Alzheimer's disease . Having to answer the same question over and over and over saps morale like few other aspects of the illness.

One common misunderstanding about the nature of repetitive questioning is that it is a request for information. Some very detailed studies carried out in the Geriatric Medicine Research Unit at Dalhousie University by Dr. France Cloutier, supported by an Alzheimer Society of Canada Post-Doctoral Research Fellowship, showed that more often, the 'purpose' of repetitive questioning is not to seek information as much as it is to seek reassurance. Thus, one way to respond to the request, is to supplementthe informative part of the answer with some support and reassurance. (For example, for the person who repeatedly asks 'When are we going to the doctor?' the answer might be not just 'We are going to the doctor tomorrow', but with emotional support added 'we are going to the doctor tomorrow, and I know that you are nervous - I am a little nervous too - but I think that they will tell us that things are getting better.')

Understanding the illness in this way - at the level of the experience of people who are going through it - is known as phenomenology. It has played a surprisingly small role in Alzheimer's disease research, but an excellent example of how it can help us get to grips with Alzheimer's disease is in the excellent book by Steven R. Sabat. The Experience of Alzheimer's Disease. Life Through a Tangled Veil. (Oxford: Blackwell, 2001).

We have also come to understand that the repetitive questions are not just a problem with memory (people do forget that they have asked the question before) but also a problem with planning. This likely is why repetitive questioning often has to do with questions about upcoming events, like a doctor's appointment, or the visit of a friend, or going on a trip.

Our most recent work on repetitive questioning was done as part of a controlled clinical trial of galantamine (Reminyly, Razadyne) in treating people with mild-moderate Alzheimer's disease. We found that most patients in this trial who set a goal for improvement in verbal repetition met that goal (about 60%) and only a few got worse (less than 10%). By contrast, less than a third of people on placebo got better, and more of them showed worsening of their verbal repetition. The full study on repetitive questioning is published in Neurology , 2007;68:1116-1121. The main report from the clinical trial was published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ 2006;174:1099-1105) and is available free on-line.



See Also:
About Dementia > Alzheimer's Disease > Early Signs
About Dementia > Alzheimer's Disease > Mild
About Dementia > Alzheimer's Disease > Severe
Learn Track Join About Us Contact Information Dementia Community Site Map
Last updated April 10, 2014
©2006 DementiaGuide Inc.
Terms of Use Your Privacy